Squirrel and Sherry pie

Game is incredibly popular around here, we have the fantastic Game Auction that takes place every Tuesday morning at the Cattle Market.  You never really know whats going to make an appearance hanging on the rails – wild boar, deer, hare, woodcock, partridge, squirrel, it’s a real mixed bag.  The squirrels normally go for between 50p and £1 depending on the crowd.  Yesterday I popped into town to pick up a newspaper and grab a brandy hot chocolate from the guy on the market, next to him was Picks Organic Farm who raise all their own meat and the quality of their beef is absolutely fantastic.  I asked if they had any veal sweetbreads at all and was met with the reply: “no, people are still a bit funny about veal… but we’ve got squirrel”.  Done, I said, I’ll take the squirrels instead.

Having only had squirrel as part of a mixed game pie before I wasn’t entirely sure about the flavours.  I’d heard they took on a nutty flavour due to their diet so thought a nice nutty Amontillado sherry would help bring that out.  I had a look online to see if there were any recipes to use as a guide but failed to find any so decided to wing it.  I didn’t want the squirrel to be overpowered by any other really strong flavours so kept it all pretty simple and made it up as I went along.

Ingredients (made 2 generously filled pies)

2 local wild grey squirrels, skinned, gutted and cleaned

1 red onion, finely diced

3/4 carrot, finely diced

1 stick celery, finely diced

2 garlic cloves

About 10 mushrooms finely sliced


1 tblsp rapeseed oil ( a good nutty one, I use Chiltern Cold Pressed)

2 thyme sprigs

Large wine glass Amontillado Sherry

Handful hazelnuts

Chicken stock (enough to cover the squirrels)

Shortcrust pastry

Puff pastry

1 beaten egg to glaze


Put your oil in a saucepan then add the onion, carrot and celery and fry gently to soften then add the garlic and a large knob of butter and the mushrooms  and continue to cook gently for about a minute before adding the 2 whole squirrels.  Allow the squirrels to just brown then add the thyme, sherry, hazelnuts and enough chicken stock to just cover, pop a lid on the saucepan and simmer really gently for about 30mins.  I had intended to cook it long and slow as its hard to tell the age of a squirrel and the older ones are tough but after 30 minutes the meat was really tender so decided to remove the squirrels and put to one side to cool.

I then reduced the saucepan contents to intensify and thicken.  Whilst this was happening I rolled out my shortcrust pasty, lined 2 small casserole dishes and baked them blind in the oven for 20 mins (filled with tinfoil and rice).  The stock was reducing well but it needed a little extra thickening so in went some more butter that I had squished some flour into to make a quick beurre maniè.

Now that the squirrels had cooled I stripped the meat off and added it back into the saucepan and seasoned with some salt and pepper.  Once the pastry was ready I gave the insides a quick brush with beaten egg, filled them with the squirrel mixture then brushed around the edges before popping a puff pastry lid on each one, creating a little hole in the centre to let the steam escape and then brushing with more beaten egg.  These then went back in the oven for about 15mins until the lids were all puffed up beautifully. Once taken out of the oven I just turned them upside down and they fell out of their little casserole pots.

I had been tasting as I went so I knew that it would be nice but I was still surprised by just how nice it was.  The nutty sherry brought out the flavour of the squirrel and allowed it to really shine.  The hazelnuts had softened but still had a bit of bite to them which was lovely against the tender meat and crisp pastry.  I served the pies with a buttery mash and a dollop of good horseradish sauce on the side.  The horseradish worked so well with the pie that next time I might just add the tinniest  amount to the pie mix.

There was a mixed reaction from people on Twitter and Facebook in regards to eating squirrel, with the overwhelming majority being hugely enthusiastic and positive about this wild, sustainable meat.  Many people shared my view that eating more grey squirrels can only be a good thing to encourage the return of our native red squirrel which has sadly been almost wiped out by the American grey impostor.

I grew up in Hong Kong where we ate things like chicken feet, intestines and trotters with gusto and you picked your seafood from a tank to be whisked away to the kitchen only to return minutes later cooked to perfection and served on a platter.  I was asked on Twitter if, seeing as I was happy to eat squirrel, would I also eat cat?  Well, no I wouldn’t but apart from the fact that I prefer not to eat my pets, it’s is also because I like my meat to have dined on a vegetarian diet (although I do eat chickens that have been running around fields snaffling slugs and worms).  My partner refuses to eat octopus as he says they are far too intelligent to eat, I on the other hand love octopus and eat it with relish.  Everyone has their own views over what animals they do or don’t eat and why, and for those who love game I cannot recommend squirrel enough.  I for one will be making this dish many times over, and if you do decide to give it a go then please do let me know how you get on. Happy cooking!

10 thoughts on “Squirrel and Sherry pie

  1. HazyP says:

    Picks sell them oven ready but if you get them from the Game Auction you will need to prep them yourself, although they are easy to prep, the same as a rabbit really 🙂

  2. wamthomas says:

    Inspired! Sounds like a great recipe, I’m going to give it a shot. Question: could you thicken the sauce by simply mashing up the mirepoix into the reduced stock?

  3. HazyP says:

    Thank you, do let me know how you get on? I wouldn’t for 2 reasons, 1: the butter really helps bring out the nuttiness and 2: the veg add different layers of texture to the sauce. The onion and celery pretty much collapse but it’s really nice to have those little cubes of soft carrot in the pie. I’m sure it would be delicious if you did though if you didn’t want to add extra butter.

  4. Sian says:

    It always interests me what people will and won’t eat. I’m not a huge fan of game – it’s often too rich for me. I have no problem with trying it, I think I’ve just realised that wood pigeon, rabbit and all those other things that London gastropubs go nuts for just aren’t for me.

    I don’t know if I’d order a squirrel pie in a restaurant, but I’d certainly try it. I can’ say no to something new, I’d just rather someone order it so I can nick a bit of their plate.

  5. HazyP says:

    I like most game but not a huge fan of pheasant, my partner loves it so there are always a few in the freezer. Hare I really love but not too keen on the butchery of it as it pongs a bit so I can only prep it on a sunny day outside when not feeling even remotely hungover! Rabbit is a good one for people who are new to game or don’t like strong gamey flavours, I think I remember Jamie Oliver once saying how he had been feeding it to Jools for years claiming it was chicken 🙂

  6. Sian says:

    Aaaah, whenever I’ve had rabbit the little fiddle bones really put me off. It seems more hassle to eat than it’s worth. I don’t remember how pheasant tastes. I know I’ve eaten it – I remember the accidental roadkill in the countryside when I was a kid!

  7. HazyP says:

    Haha! Yes good old roadkill stew! I agree about the bones, I tend to stew/braise and strip the meat from the bones for that very reason, also ferreted rabbits best as it avoids getting shot in the pot, never a good thing!

  8. Gourmet Spice Co says:

    I think this looks fab and can’t wait to make it! When I started reading the recipe, the first ingredient that sprung to mind was thyme, so pleased to see that was in there – I bet it adds a lovely flavour. I’ve no problem with eating squirrel as I don’t really see a huge leap between that and, say, rabbit or pigeon. I think it’s more the fact we didn’t all grow up eating them – it would be far more ‘natural’ then. And besides, if we weren’t supposed to eat them, they wouldn’t be wrapped in meat… 😉

  9. HazyP says:

    Haha, never heard that one before! Glad you like the sound of it, its such an easy recipe and tastes fantastic. Make sure you let me know how you get on! 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s